EDIT: Research from a 2004 study conducted by Jennifer Lansford of Duke University shows that
“while white children who were spanked exhibit more aggressive behavior as young teens, African American children who were spanked actually exhibit less aggressive behavior.”
A new study conducted by Duke University Center for Child and Family policy concluded that spanking children creates
“dumber and more aggressive children.”
(Visit them here)
Also concluded in the study is that
“1-year-olds did worse on cognitive tests as toddlers than children who were not spanked.”
Just to be clear this study was done on 2,500 low-income Black, Mexican, and White children in the US. I’ll let you read the study yourself and gain more information on different media takes yourself.
My opinion starts here:
I was spanked whooped as a child. And I harbor no regrets. And I thank my parents for whooping me as a child. And I know that some day when I have children of my own, I’ll whoop them (as needed). It is in my opinion that a good butt whooping has never hurt a child. People are confusing a loving whooping with child abuse. Two totally different categories, and not interchangeable. The two shouldn’t even be mentioned in the same context. One is not the other.
I despise people who beat their children for no other reason than hatred and the cowardliness to pick on a helpless child. The issue with spanking your child is not the same. So no other talks of child abuse need to be mentioned. Just wanted to clear that up. That’s a different post at a different time.
I have a three year old godson and I am thankful that he has a mother that has sense enough to discipline with a firm yet loving hand. There is no denying that his parents adore him and think the world of him, all the more reason they whoop him when he needs one. Kaleb doesn’t live in a home where he’s punished for everything he does. He doesn’t get a smack when he spills his juice or runs up the stairs. He gets a warning just like any other child. Or his father will remind him to be more careful with his juice next time. But Kaleb does and deserves a whooping when he’s defiant, when he does something he knows he’s not supposed to do (touch the stove, or not stop when he’s called). Thinking logically here, this is appropriate.
Take this for example, when Kaleb first began walking (around 10 months) like any other child he wanted to run away and walk alone, far away as he could from whom every he was with. No problem. He has the freedom, and he’s being watch. The problem comes as he gets older and wants to get further and further away, and you tell Kaleb to “stop, come back” and he keeps going. Potential danger. If Kaleb is walking toward the street, if Kaleb is about to walk off a high step or anything else, you need a disciplined child who listens to that command. So yes, when Kaleb did not heed his parents command he was whooped. And rightly so, it was for his own safety and for his own understanding. If your child is running into a busy street that child needs to have a healthy fear of you, for him or her to stop immediately when you call their name.
When I say fear, it needs to be the fear that we have for God (if one is religious). You have a healthy fear of God and you should, not because he’ll condemn you or hurt you or things like that, but because you respect his supreme authority and being. The parent-child relationship is not a republic nor a democracy. And that’s where I believe a lot of the problems lie. Children have been lead to believe that this is the way a relationship with a parent is supposed to be, when on the contrary, the parent is the end authority.
Because one loves their child and respects their position within the relationship we allow children to speak and be heard and have a freedom of expression, but we are also to guide them correctly and do posses the final say. That cannot be disputed. Parents are supposed to be the one’s in control. You are not a friend, you are a parent. That entails so much more.
Children ask for whoopings. Kaleb has shown me time and time again how he literally asks for a whooping. After he gets one, which he begs for by his actions and sour attitude, he’s a much lively child, he clings to his parents even more so and he posses an overall joy that was lacking prior to his loving discipline (which usually comes from mom). I would some times ask his mother why is he acting like that (flipping his eyes, whinning, doing stuff he know he’s not supposed to do) and she always responded with “he’s asking for a but whooping.” And she lets him carry on for so long, until she finally lets him pull down his pants, hands her a belt and spanks him. Afterward, he’ll cry for a few seconds, she’ll hug him and tell him how much she loves him, and from there, he’s back to his normal self. Singing, dancing and wanting his mother to join in every step of the way. I have witnessed his change, many times.
A healthy fear of one’s parent(s) is a good thing. I fear my parents, not because I fear they will slap me upside my head, but because I know there are consequences for not giving the proper respect that comes with a parent child relationship. I believe Sherri Shepherd from “The View” said it best
“a healthy fear of your parents as a child, brings forth a healthy respect for them later in life.”
Something to that effect. And I couldn’t agree more, and I never agree with Ms. Shepherd. Ever. What’s lacking today in the parent-child relationship is the respect and the mistake that spanking a child means you don’t love that child. All the contrary. You love your child therefore you take on the difficult role of tough love and discipline them accordingly for their own safety.
Now there is an exception to every rule. Every child doesn’t need a whooping to get the same effect. Some children are alright without being whooped, but some like my godson have proven that whooping is the better option. I was whooped as a child, but I didn’t need far as many as some cousins and siblings. Every child is different and parents have to adjust accordingly. Kaleb’s mother is the youngest of three siblings (older sister, older brother). She received far more whoopings than either of her siblings (and they got their fair share) but from her own mouth, she knew she needed those whoopings. Hence the reason her son needs them today, like mother like son.
Do I fault parents that don’t spank at all? A little bit. But it is there right, but I also want to see a study done on the outcome of those children. The respect factor between the parent-child later in the relationship. Some will be good, and some will be bad. Just with spanking. The biased study, gives the wrong impression. All spanking is not bad. Speak to adults (25 and up), especially within the Black community and see what the consensus is toward whoopings.
Rarely do I hear my peers speak ill of whoopings they received as a child. And some I know got complete smack downs from their parents and still respect their parents tremendously for setting them straight. I’m talking from punches in the face, to smacks in the back of the head. I have a soon to be 21-year-old cousin whose grandmother spanked him with a butcher knife (no cuts). And we’re all fine. Laugh about it today, and say what were we thinking? I needed that whooping.
Conclusion:
To each his/her own when it comes to disciplining one’s child(ren). I guess in the end we can’t knock one effort until we’ve tried it. You know what works best for your child. And you shouldn’t feel guilty in believing differently. This study was too bias to even be considered for too much discussion, but since all the out pour of yay’s and nay’s have been put out there I thought I’d join in as well. Whoopings shaped my generation (25 to 30), and those beyond us (31 and up) to the people we are today. A generation that doesn’t resemble at all those coming behind us. Those that on a smaller scale received spankings and whatnot. And clearly one can see the difference that new child rearing has produced. I SUPPORT spankings.
Recent Comments